People. Process. Systems.

Martin Munsie
28th May 2024

Why Excel is Failing Your Food Supply Chain Header Image
In a world where efficiency can make or break a business, relying on outdated tools can severely hamper your supply chain’s effectiveness. For years, Excel has been a staple in supply chain management, but it’s increasingly clear that it is failing to meet the needs of modern businesses. The limitations of Excel are becoming more apparent, and companies must look towards advanced planning solutions to stay competitive.


The Limitations of Excel in Food Supply Chain Planning

Excel has long been the go-to tool for many businesses due to its flexibility and ease of use. However, when it comes to managing complex supply chain processes, it falls short. The primary limitations include:

1. Manual Data Entry

Excel relies heavily on manual data entry, which is time-consuming and prone to human error. Mistakes in data entry can propagate through the spreadsheet, leading to significant errors in planning and forecasting. This can result in overproduction, stockouts, and other costly inefficiencies.

2. Lack of Real-Time Updates

One of the critical drawbacks of Excel is its inability to provide real-time updates. In a dynamic supply chain environment, where conditions can change rapidly, the lack of real-time data can hinder timely decision-making. Companies need up-to-date information to respond to market fluctuations, demand changes, and supply disruptions effectively.

3. Limited Collaboration Capabilities

Excel is not designed for collaborative work, making it difficult for multiple stakeholders to work on the same file simultaneously. This limitation can lead to version control issues, where different team members are working with outdated information, causing misalignment and communication breakdowns.

4. Scalability Issues

As businesses grow, their data volumes increase, and Excel struggles to handle large datasets. Complex calculations and extensive data processing can slow down the system, leading to delays and inefficiencies. Additionally, Excel’s limited capacity for intricate data manipulation can restrict a company’s ability to perform detailed analysis and make informed decisions.

5. Key Man Dependency

Often, the knowledge of how data is structured and manipulated in Excel resides with a few individuals. This creates a dependency where the absence of these key personnel can disrupt operations. Moreover, this dependency on specific individuals increases the risk of data misinterpretation and errors.


Embracing the Power of Advanced Planning Systems

Modern planning systems offer a robust alternative to Excel by managing increasing levels of complexity and data needs. These systems leverage advanced algorithms, statistical analysis, and industry-specific data to optimise food supply chain operations. Here are some key benefits:

1. Demand Forecasting

Advanced forecasting capabilities in modern planning systems take into account a wide range of factors, including historical sales data, consumer trends, promotional activities, and external influences such as weather patterns and market disruptions. By analysing this data, these systems can generate accurate demand predictions, allowing companies to better align their production and inventory levels with market needs. This leads to reduced excess inventory, minimised stockouts, and improved customer satisfaction.

2. Inventory Optimisation

Integrating demand forecasts with production constraints, lead times, and shelf-life considerations, advanced planning systems help food manufacturers optimise inventory levels. This reduces waste and ensures that products remain fresh. Optimised inventory management not only lowers holding costs but also enhances the overall efficiency of the supply chain. For instance, by maintaining optimal inventory levels, companies can prevent spoilage and ensure timely delivery of products to retailers.

3. Production Planning

Sophisticated planning engines consider various factors such as raw material availability, production capacities, and distribution networks to generate optimised production schedules. This helps minimise production costs and maximise efficiency. By ensuring that production schedules are aligned with demand forecasts and resource availability, companies can reduce idle time, improve throughput, and enhance the utilisation of their manufacturing assets.

4. Traceability and Compliance

Built-in traceability features in advanced planning systems ensure compliance with food safety regulations and enable rapid recall management. This mitigates risks associated with product recalls and protects brand reputation. With real-time traceability, companies can quickly identify and isolate any compromised products, reducing the impact of recalls on their operations and maintaining consumer trust.

5. Collaboration and Integration

Modern planning systems seamlessly integrate with other enterprise systems such as ERP (Enterprise Resource Planning), WMS (Warehouse Management System), and TMS (Transportation Management System). This integration facilitates real-time data sharing and collaboration across the entire supply chain, from suppliers to retailers. By enabling seamless information flow, these systems enhance coordination, improve visibility, and support more informed decision-making.


Making the Transition

Transitioning from Excel to a specialised supply chain planning solution may seem daunting, but the long-term benefits far outweigh the initial investment. The recent key events affecting food manufacturing within the UK underscore the need for robust systems that can react to new constraints, changing demands, and increasingly complex legislation.


Steps to a Successful Transition

1. Assess Current Processes

Evaluate the current use of Excel in your supply chain planning to identify specific pain points and areas where an advanced system could add value. This assessment should involve input from all relevant stakeholders to ensure a comprehensive understanding of the challenges and opportunities.

2. Select the Right Tool

Choose a planning system that aligns with your business needs and goals. Consider factors such as scalability, ease of integration, and user-friendliness. It is essential to involve key users in the selection process to ensure that the chosen system meets their requirements and is readily adoptable.

3. Plan for Implementation

Develop a detailed implementation plan that includes timelines, resource allocation, and training for key stakeholders. A phased implementation approach can help manage the transition more effectively, allowing for adjustments and refinements as needed.

4. Data Migration

Ensure that historical data is accurately migrated from Excel to the new system to maintain continuity and provide a foundation for advanced analytics. Data migration should be carefully planned and executed to minimise disruptions and ensure data integrity.

5. Training and Support

Provide comprehensive training for all users and establish a support system to address any issues during the transition period. Training should focus on both the technical aspects of the new system and the business processes it supports. Ongoing support is crucial to ensure that users can effectively leverage the system’s capabilities.

6. Continuous Improvement

Regularly review and optimise the use of the new planning system to ensure it continues to meet evolving business needs and delivers the expected benefits. This involves monitoring performance, soliciting user feedback, and making necessary adjustments to processes and configurations.



The move from Microsoft Excel to an advanced supply chain planning tool represents a significant strategic shift for food manufacturers. While Excel may suffice for basic tasks, the complexities of modern food supply chain management require more robust and sophisticated solutions. By embracing advanced planning systems, companies can enhance efficiency, improve decision-making, and stay competitive in a rapidly changing market.

Investing in advanced supply chain planning tools is not just about technology—it’s about future-proofing your business to thrive amidst uncertainty and change. The ability to respond swiftly to market dynamics, optimise resources, and maintain compliance with regulatory standards will be critical for success in the food manufacturing industry. Advanced planning systems provide the foundation for these capabilities, enabling businesses to navigate the complexities of the modern supply chain with confidence and agility.


If you would like support in scoping, selecting, or implementing an advanced planning solution that will get you off of Excel, then get in touch with our team today to see what we can do for you.

We are here to help.

If you have a project that could do with our expertise and knowledge, get in touch.

Fill out the form or find our details on our contact page.

    We're committed to your privacy. OptimumPPS uses the information you provide to us to contact you about our relevant content, products, and services. You may unsubscribe from these communications at any time. For more information, check out our Privacy Policy.